Thursday, January 26, 2012

FPGA vs ASIC

Definitions
FPGA: A Field-Programmable Gate Array (FPGA) is a semiconductor device containing programmable logic components called "logic blocks", and programmable interconnects. Logic blocks can be programmed to perform the function of basic logic gates such as AND, and XOR, or more complex combinational functions such as decoders or mathematical functions.

ASIC: An application-specific integrated circuit (ASIC) is an integrated circuit designed for a particular use, rather than intended for general-purpose use. Processors, RAM, ROM, etc are examples of ASICs.
FPGA vs ASIC
Speed
ASIC rules out FPGA in terms of speed. As ASIC are designed for a specific application they can be optimized to maximum, hence we can have high speed in ASIC designs. ASIC can have hight speed clocks.
Cost
FPGAs are cost effective for small applications. But when it comes to complex and large volume designs (like 32-bit processors) ASIC products are cheaper.
Size/Area
FPGA are contains lots of LUTs, and routing channels which are connected via bit streams(program). As they are made for general purpose and because of re-usability. They are in-general larger designs than corresponding ASIC design. For example, LUT gives you both registered and non-register output, but if we require only non-registered output, then its a waste of having a extra circuitry. In this way ASIC will be smaller in size.
Power
FPGA designs consume more power than ASIC designs. As explained above the unwanted circuitry results wastage of power. FPGA wont allow us to have better power optimization. When it comes to ASIC designs we can optimize them to the fullest.
Time to Market
FPGA designs will till less time, as the design cycle is small when compared to that of ASIC designs. No need of layouts, masks or other back-end processes. Its very simple: Specifications -- HDL + simulations -- Synthesis -- Place and Route (along with static-analysis) -- Dump code onto FPGA and Verify. When it comes to ASIC we have to do floor planning and also advanced verification. The FPGA design flow eliminates the complex and time-consuming floor planning, place and route, timing analysis, and mask / re-spin stages of the project since the design logic is already synthesized to be placed onto an already verified, characterized FPGA device.

Type of Design
ASIC can have mixed-signal designs, or only analog designs. But it is not possible to design them using FPGA chips.
Customization
ASIC has the upper hand when comes to the customization. The device can be fully customized as ASICs will be designed according to a given specification. Just imagine implementing a 32-bit processor on a FPGA!
Prototyping
Because of re-usability of FPGAs, they are used as ASIC prototypes. ASIC design HDL code is first dumped onto a FPGA and tested for accurate results. Once the design is error free then it is taken for further steps. Its clear that FPGA may be needed for designing an ASIC.
Non Recurring Engineering/Expenses
NRE refers to the one-time cost of researching, designing, and testing a new product, which is generally associated with ASICs. No such thing is associated with FPGA. Hence FPGA designs are cost effective.
Simpler Design Cycle
Due to software that handles much of the routing, placement, and timing, FPGA designs have smaller designed cycle than ASICs.
More Predictable Project Cycle
Due to elimination of potential re-spins, wafer capacities, etc. FPGA designs have better project cycle.
Tools
Tools which are used for FPGA designs are relatively cheaper than ASIC designs.
Re-Usability
A single FPGA can be used for various applications, by simply reprogramming it (dumping new HDL code). By definition ASIC are application specific cannot be reused.

What are FPGAs

Field Programmable Gate Arrays (FPGAs) are programmable semiconductor devices that are based around a matrix of configurable logic blocks (CLBs) connected via programmable interconnects.

What are ASICs

Application Specific Integrated Circuits (ASICs) are devices custom built for the particular design.

What are FPGA Design Advantages

    Faster time-to-market – no layout, masks or other manufacturing steps are needed No upfront NRE (non recurring expenses) – costs typically associated with an ASIC design Simpler design cycle – due to software that handles much of the routing, placement, and timing More predictable project cycle – due to elimination of potential re-spins, wafer capacities, etc. Field reprogramability – a new bitstream can be uploaded remotely

What are FPGA Design Limitations

    Power consumption – FPGAs fundamentally use a lot more power than ASICs Price – they also fundamentally cost more Speed – ASICs can still blow any FPGA away in sheer speed although design techniques can help with this issue. Density – ASIcs can still pack a lot more logic into a single chip than an FPGA IP – modern, complex IP (a complete PCI Express of Hypertransport core for example) may take up most or all of an FPGA but only 10% of an ASIC

What are ASIC Design Advantages

    Full custom capability – for design since device is manufactured to design specs Lower unit costs – for very high volume designs Smaller form factor – since device is manufactured to design specs Higher raw internal clock speeds

What are ASIC Design Limitations

    High NRE cost – for design since device is manufactured to design specs Lower unit costs – for very high volume designs Smaller form factor – since device is manufactured to design specs Higher raw internal clock speeds

http://only-vlsi.blogspot.com/2008/05/fpga-vs-asic.html

http://electronicsbus.com/fpga-vs-asic-design-verification-comparison/

1 comment:

  1. hey nice source for us,thanks for sharing the nice information of the asic design and you have done incredible job in this blog for collect the information and i show the video and this video will be awesome and provide the nice information.

    Semiconductor Design services

    ReplyDelete